SAGE Test vs. Clock Drawing Test vs. SLUMS vs. MoCA: Which Check Fits?
Compare the SAGE test, Clock Drawing Test, SLUMS, and MoCA side by side—time required, cognitive domains, self-check rules, and what to bring to your doctor.
By Tokei Health, Cognitive Health Editorial Team
If you have spent an evening searching online for a trustworthy memory check—either for yourself or for an aging parent—you have probably run into a confusing alphabet soup: Clock Drawing, Mini-Cog, SAGE, SLUMS, and MoCA. Some can be completed quietly at the kitchen table; others must be given out loud by a trained clinician. Some take three minutes; others take twenty.
Choosing the right starting point matters. Pick a test that is too long and stressful at home, and a reluctant family member may shut down before you ever reach the doctor's office. Worse, downloading and practicing an in-office exam like SLUMS or MoCA ahead of time can accidentally "teach to the test," making your doctor's evaluation less accurate.
Here is a clear, plain-English comparison of the four tools families ask about most—what each one measures, which ones belong at home versus in the clinic, and how to walk into a primary care appointment genuinely prepared.
Side-by-Side Comparison: SAGE vs. Clock + Recall vs. SLUMS vs. MoCA
| Feature | Clock Drawing + Word Recall | SAGE Test (Ohio State) | SLUMS Exam | MoCA | | :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- | | Typical Time | About 3 minutes | 15 to 20 minutes | About 10 minutes | 10 to 15 minutes | | Total Score Scale | 0–5 (Mini-Cog) or standalone clock scales | 0 to 22 points | 0 to 30 points | 0 to 30 points | | Designed for Home Self-Use? | Yes (educational baseline / visit prep) | Yes (4-page printable; bring to doctor for scoring) | No (clinician-administered verbal + written exam) | No (clinician-administered; certification required) | | Core Domains Checked | Executive planning, visuospatial layout, abstraction, short-term recall | Orientation, naming, similarities, math, memory, 3D construction, clock, trails | Orientation, calculation, animal fluency, story recall, clock drawing, shape recognition | Visuospatial/executive, naming, attention, language, abstraction, delayed recall, orientation | | Education Adjustment | Interpreted alongside clinical context | Clinician adds context for formal schooling | Separate cutoffs for less than vs. high school education | Adds 1 point for 12 years or fewer of formal schooling | | Licensing Status | Public domain task | Free for individual non-commercial download | Public domain clinical tool | Copyrighted; requires clinician training/certification | | Best Use Case | Fast, low-stress home check or rapid primary care screen | Detailed written self-administered packet before a PCP visit | Full primary care / VA follow-up for MCI or dementia | Specialist or primary care gold-standard MCI screen |
How Each Screening Tool Works (and Where It Shines)
1. Clock Drawing + Delayed Word Recall (~3 Minutes)
The Clock Drawing Test—especially paired with three-word delayed recall as in the Mini-Cog—is the fastest validated way to check executive planning, spatial layout, abstraction, and short-term memory together.
- Low test anxiety: Drawing a clock set to ten past eleven feels approachable—no four-page booklets or math problems to overwhelm someone who feels tired or nervous.
- Visual insight beyond a score: Number spacing and hand placement reveal subtle executive or visuospatial shifts that verbal questions miss.
- Safe for visit prep: Completing a printable clock drawing sheet or guided digital check gives your doctor a clean visual sample without spoiling in-office verbal exams.
Its trade-off is breadth: a three-minute screen will not test extended naming, calculations, or multi-step puzzles.
2. The SAGE Test (Ohio State, 15–20 Minutes)
Developed at The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center, SAGE is a written self-administered cognitive screen completed independently without time limits and handed to a physician.
- Four pages, 12 questions, 22 points (
17and above is generally normal,15–16aligns with mild cognitive impairment patterns, and14or below warrants fuller workup). - Four interchangeable forms for repeat tracking every six to twelve months.
- Broad written scope: Orientation, picture naming, similarities, simple change math, delayed written memory, 3D shape copying, clock drawing, category fluency, and modified trails.
SAGE works well for comfortable readers, though vision trouble, hand arthritis, or fatigue can lower scores, and Ohio State leaves scoring to clinicians rather than consumers.
3. The SLUMS Exam (~10 Minutes)
Created with the Veterans Affairs health system, SLUMS is a 30-point, 11-item exam administered out loud by a clinician.
- Public domain: Free of licensing fees, making it a staple in primary care and geriatric clinics.
- Education-adjusted cutoffs: With a high school education,
27–30is normal,21–26suggests mild neurocognitive disorder (MCI), and20or below aligns with dementia-range scores (shifting to25–30,20–24, and19or below for less than high school). - Verbal + visual tasks: Combines a 4-point clock drawing with 60-second animal naming and spoken story recall.
4. The MoCA (10–15 Minutes)
Widely used by neurologists as a sensitive Mild Cognitive Impairment (MCI) benchmark, the 30-point MoCA (26 and above traditionally normal; 23–25 interpreted alongside age and education) catches subtle executive and recall slips missed by older screens—see MMSE vs. Clock Drawing Test vs. MoCA. It requires spoken administration and official clinician certification.
Never "Practice" SLUMS or MoCA Before an Appointment
Looking up the SLUMS story or MoCA word list to quiz a loved one the night before an exam creates a practice effect—temporarily inflating their clinic score by two or three points and masking genuine MCI. Leave SLUMS and MoCA for the exam room, and stick to pre-visit tools at home.
Which Starting Point Fits Your Situation?
- Quick, calm personal baseline: Try Tokei Health's 3-minute online Clock + Word Recall check or Printable Clock Drawing Test.
- Comfortable with a 4-page written packet: Complete one SAGE form unassisted (no clocks visible) and hand all four pages to your PCP.
- Helping a parent who resists "tests": Skip long booklets; complete the private 2-minute AD8 Caregiver Checklist yourself—no patient testing needed.
- Sudden confusion over hours or days: Skip home screens entirely—rapid disorientation, drowsiness, or fever signals possible acute delirium or stroke and requires same-day urgent care.
What to Bring Alongside Any Cognitive Screen
No screening score—whether 3/5 on a Mini-Cog, 16/22 on SAGE, or 24/30 on SLUMS—diagnoses the cause of memory changes. To help a primary care clinician turn a 15-minute visit into real answers, pair your self-check with three essentials:
- A complete medication and supplement list (including over-the-counter sleep aids, allergy pills, and bladder medications—check common cognitive side effects first with our Medication & Memory Check).
- Two or three dated, concrete everyday examples from our cognitive symptoms guide (for instance, "Paid the electric bill three times in October" rather than "Seems forgetful").
- Notes on sleep, mood, vision, and hearing, which help your clinician prioritize reversible causes right away.
References
- The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center. Self-Administered Gerocognitive Examination (SAGE): Clinical Validation and Administration Overview. Journal of Neuropsychiatry and Clinical Neurosciences.
- Saint Louis University Division of Geriatric Medicine. Saint Louis University Mental Status (SLUMS) Examination. American Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry.
- MoCA Clinic & Institute. Montreal Cognitive Assessment (MoCA) Normative and Clinical Screening Guidelines. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society.
Educational disclaimer: Tokei Health (Coadia, Inc.) provides educational self-check tools and doctor-visit preparation materials—not medical advice, diagnosis, or medical services. Screening tools cannot diagnose or rule out medical conditions; always consult a qualified clinician.
Frequently Asked Questions
- What is the main difference between the SAGE test and the Clock Drawing Test?
- The Clock Drawing Test (especially when paired with delayed word recall) takes about 3 minutes and screens executive planning, spatial layout, and short-term memory. Ohio State's SAGE test is a 4-page, 15-to-20-minute written packet that tests orientation, language, calculations, reasoning, memory, and visuospatial drawing—including a clock—and is designed to be scored by a physician.
- Can I take SLUMS or MoCA on my own at home?
- No. Both the SLUMS (Saint Louis University Mental Status) exam and the MoCA (Montreal Cognitive Assessment) are interactive, clinician-administered assessments that require spoken prompts, timed verbal fluency tasks, and trained scoring. Attempting or memorizing them ahead of an appointment can create practice effects that distort your clinic evaluation.
- Why do many primary care clinics use SLUMS instead of MoCA?
- Both are 30-point, 10-to-15-minute assessments sensitive to mild cognitive impairment, but MoCA is copyrighted and requires paid clinician training and certification for routine clinical use, whereas SLUMS is freely available in the public domain with built-in score adjustments for high school education.
- How is the SAGE test scored if I download it at home?
- SAGE has 4 interchangeable printable forms, each scored out of 22 points, where scores of 17 and above are generally considered normal. Its creators recommend bringing the completed 4-page packet directly to your primary care doctor for objective scoring and clinical interpretation rather than self-diagnosing at home.
- Which cognitive check is best when an older parent feels anxious about testing?
- When someone feels overwhelmed or defensive about a 4-page written exam, starting with a brief 3-minute Clock Drawing and Word Recall check—paired with a private family observation checklist like the AD8—captures meaningful information with far less fatigue and friction.
- Does a normal score on SAGE, SLUMS, or a clock test rule out cognitive change?
- No brief test catches every early change, especially in adults with high baseline education or subtle personality and judgment shifts. If day-to-day functioning has changed—such as missed bills, medication mix-ups, or getting turned around while driving—those real-world observations warrant medical evaluation regardless of a screening score.
Take the Free 3-Minute Clock & Memory Check
Start with our free 3-minute clock & recall check — no account required — with optional printable visit-preparation packets if you are preparing for a doctor's appointment.
Free 3-minute clock check · No account required
Educational self-check software: Tokei Health (Coadia, Inc.) is not a healthcare provider and does not offer medical services, diagnosis, or medical advice. Always consult a qualified physician or pharmacist before making any health or medication decisions.